What would you do?

I saw a snippet of a thus-titled show recently in which the producers set up situations in which someone is doing something rude in public and among strangers and the object is to see who jumps in. What is unclear to me, however, is if the behavior of the antagonist is perceived as not only rude, but also as self-effacing, for aren’t people who are behaving in an undeniably rude manner also embarrassing themselves? It is further unclear whether or not those who do jump in are perceived as helpful in that manner, as saving not only the object of the rudeness (in the cases where one exists) but also saving the person from snap judgements such as ‘rude’, or ‘mean’.

And of course these are complete strangers so, what then, of situations in which someone you know, and perhaps even care about, is behaving in a manner which is widely deemed as negative or humiliating? It is then good to jump in or does that label you a busybody? Are friends and loved ones in any way obligated to try to somehow, some way, save that person from themselves, from the repercussions of stumbling around a party or offending people with callous actions and/or remarks or behaving in any one of many socially offensive behaviors? Is that caring? Or is that also rude? Is one’s job in such situations to look the other way, or to step in somehow — at the moment, after the moment, in anticipation of an upcoming moment? For what does it mean in terms of implied obligatory response in situations where one suffers from second-hand embarrassment due to the actions of another, as exacerbated by side-eye glances and slightly arched eyebrows?

To jump in at any of those past, present or future moments can be a lose-lose proposition in that the self-appointed ‘hero’ can be perceived as an annoyance, groaned about in private, one who fails to mind their own business, or worse, but yet, in some situations the reverse is a possible outcome such as an alcohol-related arrest or much much worse.

I’d like to see a show about that, in which group social interactions are set up in order to see what unfolds; in which perhaps there is money, well-being, safety, respect of one’s peers, or social-standing, in the position to be gained or lost, at stake. Because quite honestly, in such situations I know what I would do (which would be directly dependent on whether or not this is someone I care about, or even love, or merely worry for), but I don’t exactly know what is the ‘right’ thing to do. Cameras or not, life is a stage of sorts and judgment can be swift and difficult to alter. One thing I do know is that if you care enough to act you are absolutely at risk and so you best have the stomach for gambling.

And, what would you want others to do for you in such situations? What is the truly kind thing to do and is the kind thing also the socially acceptable thing to do? Is it better to mind your own business and just avoid such situations in the future? I really want to know.

 

 

3 Responses to “What would you do?”

  1. Let them make a fool of themselves. Who cares? rude clueless people don’t care so they will act out of selfishness not concern for others or how bad they look so let them do it. Not my problem.

  2. Lovejoyman Says:

    we have all tried in the past to stop someone from embarassing themself but it is useless bc they will just resent you for it . if people r too stupid to know how to act or to not drive drunk than that’s there problem. if you try to help they will hate you. they want to do what they want. they will just hang around other ppl who will let them drive drunk and think their the real friends. give it up.

  3. This is similar to a Theatre of the Oppressed performance I read about only opposite. The performance was trying to address economic inequality by appealing to peoples’ empathy and sense of justice. The set up was a man went to a restaurant and ordered a meal then “discovered” it was too expensive for him to pay. Then he attempted to get other diners to help him pay for his food by proving he was an honest man who wanted to pay.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: